Berenice Mulvanny successfully represents client in bribery case
16th March 2022
3PB specialist criminal barrister Berenice Mulvanny, pictured here, successfully represented Doctor David Turner, one of four defendants charged with numerous counts of bribery relating to his time working for the NHS on the Isle of Wight. This was a complex case concerning allegations of accepting bribes from pharmaceutical companies to promote drugs within the NHS.
The Prosecution alleged that Dr Turner and other senior NHS officials 'exploited' the health service by accepting almost £70,000 in bribes to promote prescription drugs to doctors.
Medicine boss Paul Jerram and Dr David Turner allegedly acted as 'paid influencers' for pharmaceutical companies by recommending medicines to GPs in exchange for 'secret' payments. Dr Turner, 66, was a Ventnor GP who worked as a consultant to the IW CCG and also chaired a care prescription committee which advised the CCG and was comprised of specialist nurses and doctors. Together with Paul Jerram, he ran JTRx, which stands for Jerram Turner Prescribe.
Dr Turner, a man of immedicable character and reputation, denied acting improperly and Prosecution witnesses spoke of his professionalism and genuine motivations. Dr Turner, together with the IOW CCG Medicines Management team, saved the NHS millions of pounds through his hard work and dedication.
Considerable time, money and resources have gone into investigating the four men, all of good character, and bringing them to trial. However, during the evidence of the Officer in the Case, a major flaw in the disclosure process was revealed. The Prosecution had to abandon the trial after conceding that Dr Turner and the other defendants could not have a fair trial due to the way the allegations had been investigated. The Judge directed the Jury to enter not guilty verdicts on all counts.
Investigators failed to disclose material which would have helped Dr Turner to defend himself, and ensure a fair trial. This is despite the time they had to get things right, the resources at their disposal, and the very clear guidance which the law and the Attorney-General’s Guidelines on Disclosure provide.
Press coverage can be found here.
Related Articles
-
3PB crime barrister Thomas Acworth represented DB, a vulnerable man with serious health issues, who was charged with conspiracy to transfer prohibited weapons and conspiracy to transfer ammunition. Together with others, DB was said to have converted legal, blank-firing pistols into operational, lethal handguns. The handguns were then supplied to other organised criminal groups around the country. Some were used in gangland shootings. At sentence, HHJ Real accepted Thomas’ ‘focused and realistic’ submissions about DB’s role...
Continue reading -
Nick Cotter and Graham Gilbert successfully prosecute organised crime gang in major phone fraud case
3PB's crime and regulatory barristers Nick Cotter and Graham Gilbert acted for the Crown in prosecuting an organised crime gang who defrauded major phone companies out of over £400,000 - seeing four of the five fraudsters jailed for a combined total of 11 years with the fifth, who admitted his part in the fraud conspiracy, due to appear for sentencing at a later date. The fraudsters all pleaded guilty at Portsmouth Crown Court to defrauding...
Continue reading -
3PB are delighted to announce that crime and regulatory barrister Gemma White has been appointed by Robert Courts KC MP HM Solicitor General, to the Treasury Counsel Monitoree Scheme, for a period of 3 years from 1 April 2024. Treasury Counsel are a team of specialist advocates who prosecute many of the most serious and complex cases in the country, and advise and appear on behalf of the Law Officers and other government departments. Advocates...
Continue reading -
3PB’s specialist criminal and regulatory barrister Jonathan Underhill was instructed in Operation Scowl; a complex multi-Defendant drugs case, following the National Crime Agency’s Operation Emma and Operation Venetic into the use of the "EncroChat’ network; and secured the unanimous acquittal of his client. Five of the nine Defendants proceeded to trial accused of involvement in the supply of Class A drugs operating principally over EncroChat between 2019 and 2020. They were alleged to have been...
Continue reading
