Nick Kaplan in Wordsworth Construction case sees two adjudicators' decisions set off against each other
25th March 2024
3PB construction barrister Nick Kaplan appeared for the claimant in the case of Wordsworth Construction v Inivos Limited t/a Health Spaces before Recorder Singer KC, sitting as a judge of the Technology and Construction Court (TCC). He was instructed by law firm Berry Smith LLP.
Quite unusually the Court decided to set-off two adjudicator’s decisions against each other. The Court previously confirmed in a judgment last year in FK Construction Ltd v ISG Retail Ltd [2023] EWHC 1042 (TCC) (at [20]) that this was sometimes possible, but that it would only happen in exceptional circumstances and at the Court’s discretion. It is interesting that less than a year later the Court has made a decision where it was required to do this.
Because the Court decided to set the two decisions off against each other, it had to decide what VAT was due as between the two parties since that effected the direction in which money would flow (the Court could not simply make an order for the principal sum “plus VAT as applicable”). This was issue 3 in the hearing. Although the report of the judgment does not record the Court’s conclusion on this issue, the Court decided that none of the VAT claimed by Inivos/HS was due, and some but not all of the VAT claimed by Wordworth was due.
At [55] – [56] of the judgment, the Judge had to consider whether Inivos/HS’s assertion that the first adjudicator was conflicted, invalidated the appointment of the second adjudicator. Although the Judge found, on the facts, that the appointment was not invalidated it is notable that he left the door ajar to a finding for a future court to find, on different facts, that an appointment might be invalidated by a mistaken assertion of a conflict - even if such an assertion is not made fraudulently.
To read a full copy of the judgment, please click here.
If you wish to contact Nick, or instruct him, please email his clerk Joe Townsend on [email protected] or by calling him on 020 7583 8055.
Related Articles
-
3PB's construction barrister Nick Kaplan has been instructed to represent builder Keith Elliott to recover payments, awarded by an adjudicator, from a company run by Australian fashion tycoon Donna Ida Thornton in a new High Court action. This follows a ruling in January 2024 by an adjudicator that Ms Thornton must pay the contractor £236,000 for the restoration work that his company completed at her 16-bedroom Devon mansion. The case is ongoing and is receiving...
Continue reading -
3PB Barristers’ (3 Paper Buildings) Nick Kaplan and Mariya Peykova have contributed to the latest issue of ThoughtLeaders4 Disputes. Mariya’s article “Data Adequacy and International Relations: The Pitfalls of a Shifting Human Rights Landscape”, published on pages 11-12, explores the connection between EU data adequacy decisions and human rights records. In her article, Mariya explores how the undermining of the existing human rights framework could alter how the EU views the UK’s ability to provide...
Continue reading -
3PB construction barrister Nick Kaplan recently acted as sole counsel for Bellway Homes in a dual enforcement and Part 8 claim in the TCC in the case of Bellway Homes v Surgo Construction, before HHJ Davies. Judgment was handed down yesterday morning. Nick was instructed by Gateley Legal. In its enforcement claim, Bellway claimed circa £1.1 million, which it had been awarded by an adjudicator (Jonathan Cope) following a true valuation of the parties’ interim...
Continue reading -
3PB is delighted to announce that commercial disputes and construction barrister Philip Bambagiotti, who is joint -qualified at the bar in both England and Australia, has been appointed onto the International Dispute Resolution & Risk Management Institute (IDRRMI) Panel of Senior Certified International Arbitrators. Philip Bambagiotti is a top ranked barrister and arbitrator with over 30 years experience. He is well known for his work as counsel and arbitrator in international arbitrations involving disputes over...
Continue reading
