Katherine Anderson leads Jim Hirschmann in SEN case before CoA
26th March 2026
3PB's barristers Katherine Anderson and Jim Hirschmann acted in the case London Borough of Hillingdon v AP & Anor [2026] EWCA Civ 216. Jim was led by Kath and represented the respondents in this Special Educational Needs (SEN) case before the Court of Appeal (CoA).
This case concerned two main issues consisting of whether the child needed residential provision and the extent to which section 9 of the Education Act 1996 imposed a positive duty upon it to investigate the cost effectiveness of the provision it ordered.
The Court of Appeal heard the arguments and ultimately agreed with the Respondents that this claim was academic. There was not an active dispute between the parties upon which to rule. Nor did the wider public interest justify the Court exercising its discretion to determine the matter. The appeal was therefore dismissed.
To read the full judgement, please click here.
To contact or instruct Jim or Katherine, please email their clerks Tom Cox on [email protected] / Gemma Faulkner on [email protected] or call 0330 441 7572.
Related News
-
3PB is delighted to announce that Suzy Martin and Hannah Earle, CCMS Team Managers, have been shortlisted for ‘Fees Team of the Year’ at the Institute of Barristers’ Clerks’ inaugural Awards Evening 2026. The awards ceremony will take place in the Old Hall at Lincoln’s Inn on Friday 8 May 2026. The evening will begin with a drinks reception, offering an opportunity to connect with colleagues from across the profession over drinks and canapés, followed...
Continue reading -
3PB's second six pupil barrister, Juliet Osborne, and criminal law barrister, Nate Lara, have written an article titled ‘A New Suspended Reality – Significant Reform to Suspended Sentence Orders’. In this piece, they examine the Sentencing Act 2026, which received Royal Assent on 22 January 2026 and outlines the key provisions set to reshape sentencing law. They explore how these reforms aim to address the ongoing pressure on the UK’s prison system, both by reducing...
Continue reading -
3PB is supporting the annual Mooting Competition organised by Nottingham Law School's Mooters' Guild to celebrate International Women’s Day, taking place on Thursday 26th March 2026. The moot sees students debate consent to harm and whether a piercing can amount to female genital mutilation. The moot problem was written by Alexandra Madaras. 3PB’s Danielle Gotts St. Clair and Emma Shiels will be serving as judges for this year’s moot. Danielle founded the competition in 2019...
Continue reading -
3PB's criminal law barrister Kate Davies saw immediate success after her recent return from a sabbatical, when she secured two not guilty verdicts for her client to charges of both GBH and ABH. The prosecution had alleged her client had taken someone to ground and then assaulted them repeatedly causing injuries. The defence was that it was an accident. Kate was instructed by Rio Kellman of specialist criminal defence solicitors firm, Renshaw Derrick, whose client...
Continue reading
