Nick Kaplan successful in payment adjudications case of Bellway Homes v Surgo Construction
9th January 2024
3PB construction barrister Nick Kaplan recently acted as sole counsel for Bellway Homes in enforcement proceedings in the case of Bellway Homes Limited -v Surgo Construction Limited, before DJ Baldwin, in which judgment was handed down by the Technology and Construction Court (TCC) in Liverpool this morning. Nick was instructed by Gateley Legal.
The proceedings raised a question which frequently arises in payment adjudications, but which has until today remained undecided by the courts. In essence the question was: Can a single Adjudication Notice refer a claim for payment on both a smash and grab basis and a true value basis, or does that fall foul of the prohibition on referring multiple disputes?
Nick successfully argued that a reference which advances a true value claim in the alternative to a smash & grab claim can, if framed correctly, be brought within the confines of a single notice as two alternative routes to recovery of the same (or a single) remedy.
The judgement can be read in full here.
To contact Nick, please email him on [email protected]. To instruct him, or see about his availability, please contact his clerks Steve Evers on [email protected] or Joe Townsend on [email protected] or by calling either of them on 020 7583 8055.
Related Articles
-
3PB construction barrister Nick Kaplan recently acted as sole counsel for Bellway Homes in a dual enforcement and Part 8 claim in the TCC in the case of Bellway Homes v Surgo Construction, before HHJ Davies. Judgment was handed down yesterday morning. Nick was instructed by Gateley Legal. In its enforcement claim, Bellway claimed circa £1.1 million, which it had been awarded by an adjudicator (Jonathan Cope) following a true valuation of the parties’ interim...
Continue reading -
3PB's construction barrister Nick Kaplan has been instructed to represent builder Keith Elliott to recover payments, awarded by an adjudicator, from a company run by Australian fashion tycoon Donna Ida Thornton in a new High Court action. This follows a ruling in January 2024 by an adjudicator that Ms Thornton must pay the contractor £236,000 for the restoration work that his company completed at her 16-bedroom Devon mansion. The case is ongoing and is receiving...
Continue reading -
3PB construction barrister Nick Kaplan appeared for the claimant in the case of Wordsworth Construction v Inivos Limited t/a Health Spaces before Recorder Singer KC, sitting as a judge of the Technology and Construction Court (TCC). He was instructed by law firm Berry Smith LLP. Quite unusually the Court decided to set-off two adjudicator’s decisions against each other. The Court previously confirmed in a judgment last year in FK Construction Ltd v ISG Retail Ltd...
Continue reading -
3PB's Nick Kaplan and Keating Chambers’ Brenna Conroy (pictured here) are delivering a joint talk this week at Arbrix's Spring Conference on Saturday 16th March 2024. The conference is an annual meeting of RICS arbitrators and adjudicators, notably chartered surveyors and other independent property experts. Nick and Brenna will be speaking about the recent decision in Bellway Homes v Surgo Construction in which they both appeared on opposite sides. The case is of huge significance...
Continue reading
