Jonathan Underhill secures acquittal at trial of S.18 wounding following collapse of prosecution case
15th February 2024
3PB's crime and regulatory barrister Jonathan Underhill’s client CW was charged with a serious allegation of wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm (GBH) following a violent incident inside his own home in 2021. CW raised, and maintained, self-defence at trial.
Over the course of careful and decisive cross examination, the complainant admitted not having told the complete truth to the police; accepting that he had failed to mention his own consumption of Class A drugs that night, and agreed that his account was incomplete and inaccurate. The complainant did however maintain that he had not caused any injuries to CW in the course of the incident, and that CW was the only aggressor.
Praised by the Trial Judge for his “dogged persistence” in pursuing failures in both the police investigation and prosecution disclosure; Jonathan’s efforts unearthed forensic and photographic evidence showing significant injuries to CW, including deep lacerations, significant bruising and bleeding, as well as a human bite mark. The material had been obtained by police, but never submitted to the Crown Prosecution Service and was only uncovered by Jonathan’s efforts at trial.
Following defence submissions, the Prosecution conceded that there was no longer a reasonable prospect of conviction, and the case was abandoned.
Jonathan was instructed by Patricia Sheehan of Owen & Sharpe Solicitors.
To instruct Jonathan, or see about his availability, please email Jonathan's clerk, Stuart Pringle on [email protected] or call him on 01962 868884.
Related Articles
-
3PB Barristers’ specialist crime and regulatory barrister, Holly Fagan, secured not guilty verdicts for her client accused of engaging in coercive and controlling behaviour over a 4-year relationship, and one charge of assault by beating. Holly’s client accepted that it was a toxic and dysfunctional relationship but did not accept the criminal allegations. Holly’s detailed s28 cross-examination of the complainant highlighted the weaknesses and inconsistencies in her account. The unused material proved crucial to the...
Continue reading -
3PB's crime and regulatory barrister Nicholas Cotter (pictured here), led by Mark Wyeth KC, has just completed a three-month trial at the Central Criminal Court in which his client was acquitted of conspiracy to murder The client was alleged to be involved in a gangland shooting in a nightclub, which was indicted at the outset as a conspiracy to murder. Following trial, the client was found guilty of a firearms offence but acquitted of all...
Continue reading -
3PB’s specialist criminal and regulatory barrister Jonathan Underhill was instructed in Operation Scowl; a complex multi-Defendant drugs case, following the National Crime Agency’s Operation Emma and Operation Venetic into the use of the "EncroChat’ network; and secured the unanimous acquittal of his client. Five of the nine Defendants proceeded to trial accused of involvement in the supply of Class A drugs operating principally over EncroChat between 2019 and 2020. They were alleged to have been...
Continue reading -
Four 3PB barristers secure acquittals for two defendants in major Conspiracy to Supply cocaine trial
Four 3PB criminal law barristers - Nick Robinson, Tom Evans, David Jenkins and Oliver Hirsch (pictured top left to bottom right) - have successfully defended two clients in a major Conspiracy to Supply Class A drugs trial, following Operation Krill which was an extensive surveillance operation lasting more than a year. Three individuals were charged with Conspiracy to Supply cocaine and two stood trial in December 2023. AD was alleged to have been the head...
Continue reading
